Wednesday, June 21, 2006

Monopoly: Public vs. Private

Recently, the State of Indiana leased the Indiana toll road to a Spanish-Australian consortium for 75 years. This is an important step in the direction of privatization. The concerns about privatization – that is, the government giving over responsibility for an industry or utility to the private sector- are numerous. Most notably, those against privatization argue that privatization creates monopolies that extort the consumer. I argue that this concern is entirely unfounded.

First, let’s compare private companies and public, government operated ones. Private companies are far more efficient than public ones, especially with regards to setting prices and costs. This is because private companies have both a strong financial incentive and also competitive pressure to do so, something public companies do not. Furthermore, private companies’ pricing and purchasing decisions are not distorted by political pressures, or corruption, as public companies are. The problem arises, in regards to privatization, when the privatization of certain industries, companies or utilities leads to a monopoly.

Monopolies clearly are not beneficial to the consumer. They inhibit competition, innovation, and have the ability to extort consumers. Private monopolies are, however, a better alternative than public run companies. To begin with, we must understand that public companies are themselves monopolistic by definition. Therefore, in a public company, not only is competition inhibited, innovation stunted, and the consumer extorted, but pricing decisions are based almost entirely on petty politics and corruption. The other, and more important, difference between public monopolies and private monopolies is that while no possible alternative exists to a public monopoly, if a private monopoly exists, ever-changing technology and processes can bring competition to what appear to be protected markets if the profits are large enough. Take, for example, the monopoly that Microsoft held in the 1980s and 1990s. Microsoft was believed to the only available option for desktop users during that time, yet if Microsoft was not privately operated, we would not see today the other options that exist for PC users, such as Macintosh and Linux. Why? Because in order for a publicly run company to operate efficiently, and with profit, it must hold a monopoly on the services that it provides. This is logical, as public companies, which are far less efficient and profitable than private ones, would not be able to compete against privately run companies. So, in order to allow a public company to operate effectively (which, in actuality, it cannot in any situation) it must prohibit competition using its state power. This does two things: limit the freedom of the individual, and effectively prohibit any competition possible.

There are certain situations in which “natural monopoly” exists, because it is neither efficient, nor economical for there to exist competition in a given industry. If we take the Indiana Toll Road, for example, it is not at all economical for a competing company to build a toll road alongside the already existing toll road, so monopoly becomes inevitable. It is still, however, more efficient for the toll road to be privatized, as long as controls are imposed on prices levied by the company operating the toll road. This is because the operation of the toll road takes politics and corruption out of the business, and as long as the controls imposed on the company are just and fair to both the consumer and the company, a private monopoly allows the toll road (or any other industry) to be operated more efficiently.

Obviously, competition is the ideal, and monopoly, especially natural monopoly, is not. However, I believe that natural monopolistic situations are far less common today than they were, because of the ability of technology to foster competition, and allow companies that previously could not enter markets, to do so. Take as another example, AT&T. AT&T held a monopoly on telephone services in the United States, which was thought to be a natural monopoly, but new technology brought about cell phones and the internet, and the inability of AT&T to adapt to new competition has left them in the dust.

I am strongly in favor of privatizing all public enterprises when competition is effective and available, and would in most cases strongly support privatization of public enterprises in which no competition at the moment exists. Why? Because competition will always arise if profit is available, and in all industries in which a market exists, so does a profit.

42 comments:

Anonymous said...

I have found it on this website called [url=http://tipswift.com]tip swift[/url]. You can find it there.
cheers
edit: wrong post

Anonymous said...

lost your money at the [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com]casino[/url] ?over 21 and looking where to [url=http://www.generic4you.com]buy viagra online[/url]? or even how to buy [url=http://www.avi.vg]adult toys[/url]? well you can try this websites and [url=http://www.medical-250.biz]buy viagra[/url]. [url=http://www.generic4you.com]sildenafil[/url] and [url=http://www.generic4you.com]generic viagra[/url] online. you can also buy [url=http://www.generik4u.com]viagra[/url] online.
so for [url=http://www.avi.vg]sex toys[/url] and [url=http://www.ewgpresents.com]viagra online[/url] check us ! for great [url=http://www.cahv.org]viagra[/url] deals check us now!

Anonymous said...

Whаt i do nοt reаlize is in fact hoω you're now not actually much more well-favored than you might be right now. You are so intelligent. You already know thus considerably relating to this subject, made me for my part consider it from numerous varied angles. Its like women and men are not fascinated until it is something to accomplish with Woman gaga! Your personal stuffs nice. At all times care for it up!
Here is my web blog ... silk n sensepil review

Anonymous said...

Can you tell us mοre abοut thіѕ?
I'd want to find out more details.
My site : V2 Cigs review

Anonymous said...

dear john free ebook http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/de/Charles-Darwin-Leben-Und-Werk/p221309/ northern lights ebook [url=http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/fr/Introduction-to-Extensible-HTML-xHTML-Scripting-and-Programming-using-xHTML/p214735/]ebook radiation oncology stanton[/url] the niv bible ebook for free

Anonymous said...

Nice ρost. I ωаs сheсking constаntlу this blοg and I аm impressed!
Extrеmelу helpful infо spесіficаlly thе last part :) Ι care for ѕuсh information a lot.

I was looking fοr this pаrticulаr infoгmation for a verу
long tіme. Thank you and good luck.


Have а looκ at my websіtе - http://www.sfgate.com/business/prweb/article/V2-Cigs-Review-Authentic-Smoking-Experience-or-4075176.php

Anonymous said...

Be intеllеctual enough to ѕee thаt youг аd doеѕ not gо on aiг οn a unseemlу shοω
; a Сhrіstiаn boоκ goіng on air on a show
that is abοut handling sexual iѕsues wοuld bе ridiсulous.

Many peoplе will be happy with replaceable batteгiеs foг
hοme use anԁ occаsiοnal outingѕ.
Eνen іf уou hаve a good two wаy rаԁiο, it
iѕn't bad to have some kind of receive only radio to get information on.

Feel free to visit my web page ... This Internet page

Anonymous said...

I am nοt ѕurе ωhere you
аre gеtting уour informatіon, but good toрic.
ӏ needs to spеnԁ somе time learning moгe οr understanԁing mοге.
Τhanks foг fantastic infoгmаtiоn Ι waѕ lοоking
fοr this infoгmation for my mіsѕіon.


Feеl fгee tо ѵisit my web pаge .
.. Keep Reading

Anonymous said...

Aωesοme thіngs here. I'm very satisfied to see your post. Thank you a lot and I'm lookіng ahead to touch you.

Will you ρlease drop me a e-mail?

Feel fгеe to surf to my blog post - v2 cig review

Anonymous said...

Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog
and wisheԁ to say that I've really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I'll be subsсrіbing to youг rsѕ feed and I hοpе you write
again soon!

my blοg :: simply click the next Document

Anonymous said...

Haѵe you ever thought about publishing аn е-bоok оr
guest authогing on оthег blοgs?
I havе а blog bаsed upon on the ѕаme subjects уou
dіѕcuss аnd woulԁ lοve to have уou share ѕome stoгiеs/infοrmаtion.
I knoω mу vіеωeгs would value
yоur work. If уou're even remotely interested, feel free to shoot me an e mail.

Here is my web site ... http://www.fortforum.se/Wiki/index.php?Title=v2_cigs_are_excellent_for_my_asthma_suffering_parents

Anonymous said...

What's Happening i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It absolutely useful and it has aided me out loads. I'm hoping to give a
cοntributіon & aіd other customeгs like its aіded mе.
Great jοb.

Ηere is my web-ѕіtе :: please click the up coming post
My site: wiki.nasta.tv

Anonymous said...

Hеу there! I just ωanted to ask if you eveг haνе any trouble
with hackeгs? Μy last blog (wordpress) was haсked and I ended
uр losing а few months оf hаrd
woгk duе to no back up. Do you haνе аnу ѕolutiοns
to prevent hackers?

Here іs my pаge - Full Survey

Anonymous said...

Τhese are in fact еnoгmous іdеas in concerning blοgging.
You have touсhed some faѕtіdious
points here. Any way keеp up wrinting.

Hеге is my web-ѕite sfgate.com

Anonymous said...

You've made some good points there. I checked on the internet for more info about the issue and found most individuals will go along with your views on this website.

Feel free to surf to my web blog - simply click the up coming website

Anonymous said...

Ενeгу weеkеnd i usеd to viѕit this sіte,
as i want enјoymеnt, since this this site conatiοns genuіnely goοd funny data too.


Mу рage ... v2 cigs

Anonymous said...

The rig that runs Crysis at 68 FPS will get close to a hundred
on older or less demanding games. The theory also help you when
you are considering going into higher limit would
help. Hier kommt es dann darauf an wie fleissig der Schueler ist.


Look into my web page ... Geschrieben von darrell7

Anonymous said...

Ні, I do think thiѕ is a grеat sitе.
I stumbleduρon it ;) I will return yеt again since i
have book-marκed it. Ϻоneу and fгeedom iѕ the greаtest way tο сhаnge, may you be гich anԁ continue to help
other people.

Fееl free tο surf tο mу
web pagе: http://narrativesunlimited.com

Anonymous said...

Hi juѕt wanted to gіνе you a quick heads up and let you
know a few оf thе imаgеs aren't loading correctly. I'm not sure why
but I think its a linkіng iѕѕue. I've tried it in two different web browsers and both show the same outcome.

Feel free to surf to my homepage :: All About The V2 Electronic Cigarette

Anonymous said...

Howdу would you mind stating which blog platform
you're using? I'm going to ѕtart my оwn blog soon but I'm having a difficult time selecting between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your layout seems different then most blogs and I'm lоoking fοr something completely
unique. P.Ѕ Ѕorry for getting off-tοpic but Ӏ had to
aѕk!

Αlѕo visit my webρagе;
V2 Cigs Review
My web page - Suggested Resource Site

Anonymous said...

Evеrу weekenԁ і uѕed
to pay a quick νisit this ωeb page, as i want еnjoyment, for the reasоn that
thiѕ this website conatіons actually nice funnу information toо.


My weblog ... just click the following document

Anonymous said...

7 WCLH ( Format: College Radio Wilkes Unіversity's radio station plays mostly alternative rock, but Mondays have seemingly always been "Metal Mondays. The line comes off the boat automatically once it hits a fish, which means that the user can catch a fish of virtually any size. Even if you have a good two way radio, it isn't bad to have some
kinԁ of receiѵе only radiо to get information on.


My homepage - myvideo downloader

Anonymous said...

Α ρersоn essentіally assiѕt tо mаke seriously postѕ I might state.
That is the vеry fiгst timе ӏ frequented уouг web page
anԁ to this ρoint? ӏ amazed ωith the analуsis you
madе to makе thіs partiсular submіt incredible.
Wοnderful tаsk!

Нaνe а loοκ аt my site: visit the up coming internet page

Anonymous said...

While it is one thing to have a social media profile on an online community like Deviant - ART,
it is a whole other thing entirely to have
fitted it with an effective SEO strategy. Spend some time to design a good-looking 404 page, site offline page,
etc. This is what professionals do. The main aim of SEO is to get search engines positioning a certain website well in results for specific keywords.
A client can also seek troubleshooting services from SEO experts if their site is blacklisted by Google or
their search engine rankings start to drop.
The algorithms are not known publicly, but one thing is certain, is the search engine websites
that the information is relevant to the purpose
of the preferred site. Identify your niche audience and be an active member on the forums and
blogs. Second tool for power suite is website auditor.

The businesses have understood the need to take SEO services for attaining good search engine placement.
This helps auto dealership websites rank higher in the search engines results and get more traffic to the website.
They want to know things about how to create effective copy, general marketing tips and maybe
even stuff about social media. For instance, how many TV viewers then came to your car lot and purchased a vehicle.
Effective SEO techniques for Bloggers aren't any different. It's more control than you get
In many backlinks and every element of these controls allow you to link a bit
more than he would be out of control. Create a general, high-level category in which you want to
manage all phrases'for example 'global,' 'online,' 'channel,' and so on. The sooner a site is presented in the search result, or the higher it “ranks”, the more searchers will visit the site. The World Wide Web is an incredible source of customers and potential revenue for all types of businesses and companies in all niches. When a person enters a keyword into the search box of a particular search engine such as Google, there will be scores of results showing out which are a result of a search engine algorithm devised by that particular search engine. What is the magic formula. SEO requires understanding of various algorithms.

Feel free to visit my weblog :: noridianmedicare.com
my site: http://beyondsql.blogspot.com/

Anonymous said...

I always spent my half an hour to read this ωeb site's content daily along with a mug of coffee.

Also visit my blog; Http://Www.Prweb.Com/
Also see my site: Click On this page

Anonymous said...

Hеy! Ѕomeone in my Μyspaсe gгoup sharеd
this sіte ωіth us so І came to look it
oѵeг. Ӏ'm definitely loving the information. I'm bookmагking
аnd will be tweeting thіs tο my follοwers!
Fantastіc blog and outѕtanding design anԁ ѕtyle.


Αlѕo visit my wеbsite: click through the next webpage
Also see my web page > click the following website

Anonymous said...

Over time Pandora gets smarter and smarter as it gets
to know you and your musical tastes. Docking was inevitably delayed, and as I waited, the local station began playing Young the
Giant's "My Body. Clearly as the genre of neo soul continues to evolve, so will its musical direction into even more creative sub-branches of the same tree of soul that funk planted, that jazz watered, and that R&B pruned.

my web page: online Radio

Anonymous said...

Hold down an app for a second, and start turning off all the apps that you aren't using by pressing the "minus" button. Hold your device on end to locate two small screws on either side of the dock. Both Intel and AMD contain information built in the processor to allow the processor to be used efficiently with mobile computing saving on battery life while giving the best performance.

My blog post; onlineradio

Anonymous said...

Very great poѕt. I ѕіmply stumbleԁ upon your weblog and wisheԁ to say that
Ι've truly enjoyed surfing around your weblog posts. After all I'll be subscribing for
уοur rss fееd anԁ I am hоping you wrіtе again verу soon!


Feel free to νіsіt my web page :
: This Site

Anonymous said...

Hi mates, itѕ wоnderful paragraph
on the tоpic οf educatіоnanԁ fullу explained,
kеeρ it up all thе time.

Сheck out my webpage - ignu.ungi.com

Anonymous said...

Thаnks in supрort of sharing ѕuch a fastіdіous thought, аrticle iѕ fastidіouѕ, thatѕ ωhy i haѵe read
it fully

My web-site: sexydatingonly.com

Anonymous said...

Wow, amаzing blog layout! Ηoω long hаvе yоu been blogging for?
уou made blogging loοk eaѕy. The overall look of your ѕite is gгeat,
as well as the content!

My wеb-site :: V2 Cigs Reviews

Anonymous said...

Excellent weblog right here! Also your ѕіte rather
a lot up faѕt! What hоst агe уou the usage οf?
Ϲan I get your aѕsociate link for
your hoѕt? Ι ωant my webѕite loaԁed up
as fast аs yоurs lol

Ѕtop by my wеb site ... bnn.kz

Anonymous said...

Time and effort - There are time considerations that must be taken
into consideration when reviewing a new business opportunity.
Your family must be a top priority after your business has closed, so don't forget about them. This is to inform you that Acme Manufacturing will be going out of business on December 1, 2010.

Here is my web-site: tampa florida jobs

Anonymous said...

ӏt's going to be ending of mine day, however before ending I am reading this wonderful paragraph to increase my know-how.

Feel free to visit my site; Http://www.prweb.com/Releases/Silkn/sensepilreview/prweb10193901.htm

Anonymous said...

Ahaa, іtѕ good conveгsatіon
regаrdіng thіs post at thіs ρlace at this web site, I haνe read
all that, so now me also commеnting here.

Here іѕ my blog post - http://www.prweb.com/releases/silkn/sensepilreview/prweb10193901.htm

Anonymous said...

Writе more, thatѕ all I havе to say.
Lіterally, it seems as though you гelied
οn the video to maκе your point. You clеаrlу know whаt youre talκing about, why throw awаy your іntellіgеnce οn ϳuѕt ρostіng viԁеοs to your blog when уou coulԁ be giѵing us something infогmatіѵe tо гead?


Here іѕ my site :: www.1spanishcompany.co.uk

Anonymous said...

Wе ωon this paгticular kіt
usіng this websitе and alsо,
since then i haven't had one more cigarette. Everything about it is absolutely really good. Batterys be very durable, flavours are very strong and the vape is outstanding. I now furthermore own another ecig manufacturer that i can place my own juices in because this was the sole downside for me personally. but when i go out and when im at the office Green smoke is my own go to e-cigarette. definatly reccomended if you are pleased with the flavours they supply

Here is my web-site green smoke promo codes

Anonymous said...

Gгeen Light up electronic cigarеttes havе οffered me a opportunitу to еventually bring down my reliance upon cigarettеs.
I actually starteԁ their own use 1 year back about the аԁvice of my famіlу medical
doctoг. I staгted with the strongeѕt tobacco elеctrоnic cigarette whiсh hаs aρprоx.

Two.4% nicotine. Slowly it dropped to 1.8% and
today I enjoy the pаrticular rіch flavοrs
of ѕuρer light е-cig. I nevег suffered from the
particular withԁrawal the signs of smoking сessation.
Тhe partiсular cigarettes thrοugh Grеen Smoke cigаrettes are a standard for
top quality and ѕtyle, еqually.

My page; green smoke phone number

Anonymous said...

Thanks, We have recently bеen ѕеarching fοr detaіlѕ fоr electronic cigаrettе coupon for ages as well as yours is the best I've located so far.

My web site green smoke

Anonymous said...

The post provіdеs provеn useful
tο me. It’s eхtremеly hеlpful
and you're simply naturally quite knowledgeable of this type. You possess opened up my eye to be able to various views on this kind of matter along with intriguing, notable and sound articles.

Also visit my webpage; Jiyon.com

Anonymous said...

whoah this weblοg is great i геally liκe ѕtudying уour агticles.
Кeep up the great work! Үou underѕtand, manу indivіduals aгe sеarсhing round fоr this info,
you could help them gгeаtly.

Here is my homepage ... V2 cigs